The difficulty with using the TA is the …

Comment posted Axed Argylls deployed to Olympic Games security by newsroom.

The difficulty with using the TA is the impact on the economy of employers losing 3,500 staff at short notice.

This part time nature of TA membership and the impact on businesses of using it at a serious level, also casts doubt on the achieveability of the MoD’s plan to double its size and use it more intensively in theatres of war, with the new slimmed down army.

Recent comments by newsroom

  • Save Castle Toward campaign brings it on home to Walsh and MacQueen
    As we understand it, this session was permitted to be open to the public only just before it began.
  • Can anything address the disease in Argyll and Bute Council?
    That ‘ultimate authority’, Steve, is more apparent than real.
    The majority of councillors have little idea of the detail of any issue.
    They are low paid, part timers. Many glaze over at the sight of numbers rather than words; and officers make sure to give them brick sized blocks of papers to read – and frequently at the last minute before a meeting – to keep them as uninformed as possible.
    Papers presented to council meetings carry – helpfully upfront, the officers’ recommendations on the actions to be taken – and funnily enough, those recommendations are usually nodded through by the woodentops.
    The very occasional independent minded spirit is bullied by being told serially that their motions are incompetent. They also find direct questions unable to dig out straight answers. They are forbidden to speak directly to staff on the groun but are directed to put questions to the relevant executive – who knows just how to deal with them.
    Confident and capable councillors can and do override these obstructions and insist on the authority they possess. But to make a difference you need the majority of elected members of a council to be of this calibre and self-confidence – which is rare. In general, there aren’t too many of these`; some are brand new to the job and can be easily fooled; and others have been burned off quickly by these deliberately neutralising and intimidating tactics.
    The balance of power between councillors and officers is a bit like the bad old joke: ‘What’s the difference between true love and herpes?’ Answer: ‘Herpes is for ever.’
    Councillor face regular re-election with the membership of the chamber changing from one election to the other. Officers can generally stay put, play the game, creep their way up the ladder and hang on there like a limpet.
    Time is always on the officers’ side and time is what shapes any culture.
    We are not saying a change of culture is impossible but it is very hard indeed to bring about – which is why we made this ‘emergency response to formal failure’ proposition. It’s the most effective – and achievable – approach we can think of.
  • Castle Toward decision cannot be acceptable to South Cowal community
    Most wretched of all is the fact that Castle Toward in its present state clearly is not worth more on the market than the community were able to pay for it.
    If the council were now to go on to sell it at some stage for no substantial amount more than £750k at today’s prices, having continued to pay £22.5k to £25k per month to insure and secure it while they watch its deterioration continue and accelerate – how will they account for having chosen yesterday to prevent it being sold for £750k to one if their own communities?
    And how will they account for what will inevitably be a declining population and a declining local economy in Cowal and in South Cowal?
    One thing is certain.
    It is now incumbent on this council administration to dispose of Castle Toward in very short order and for a sum very considerably in excess of what the community were able to pay.
    Councillors supporting SCCDC should now make a ritual point of formally asking the Council Leader every month, in writing, for information on the progress of disposing off Castle Toward; for information on the current marketing and sales strategy being used; and for information on the additional cost of re-marketing the property – and publish each response.
  • Too little to late – ADP extends local service providers contracts by a month
    Absolutely correct.
  • Too little to late – ADP extends local service providers contracts by a month
    They were deaf to all requests until the volume got too high.
    This is no concession. It is a desperate attempt to play a ‘Get out of jail free’ card.
    There is a lot more to come.

powered by SEO Super Comments

3 Responses to The difficulty with using the TA is the …

  1. I don’t suppose I’m the only one to wonder what will happen in future when our army has been cut by another 20,000. Say, for example, another foot and mouth outbreak coinciding with our forces being fully committed to another of the vanity wars which seem to have become a rite of passage for our recent prime ministers. Shudder.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. I do understand why officers of the British Army have to used to provide security at the Olympics. Surely members of T A could beused at a fraction of the cost.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • The difficulty with using the TA is the impact on the economy of employers losing 3,500 staff at short notice.

      This part time nature of TA membership and the impact on businesses of using it at a serious level, also casts doubt on the achieveability of the MoD’s plan to double its size and use it more intensively in theatres of war, with the new slimmed down army.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


All the latest comments (including yours) straight to your mailbox, everyday! Click here to subscribe.