Comment posted on Pilots concerned on wind farm generated air turbulence by Karl Hughes
Unless you wish to discuss our feathered aviators! and what happens when they are hit by a turbine blade…! warning this is pretty sad.
Karl Hughes also commented
- Tim rewind:this was the catalyst
Karl Hughes says:
July 2, 2012 at 7:04 pm
Agreed…but we also have to change in a sustainable manner…like you say, we are a small, in geographical terms, nation…and as such, we are far less able to absorb large physical changes (industrialisation) in the way we deploy instruments of change industrial wind power stations
Local up is the obvious answer…not state down…and definately not state sponsored commercialism down. This methodology has a proven track record in some developing nation,,,for example, many of the rural areas of Western Africa…even her in Scotland…
We can lead by example…but deployment of large scale industrial wind power stations is a plinian victory in the face of massive and ever increasing energy use and co2 release related to China, India and the US, etcetera…seriously, what do we gain except empty moral high ground, the destruction or damage of our own environment…for the sake of $$$$$$$$$$ in foreign pockets.
Is this so wrong ? We are leading the way in a reduced hydrocarbon use and thats admirable…and we can go back historically and say sorry we did not know an industrial revolution would kick off global warming and accelerated climate change…much the same as we can say sorry for slavery…it gives some close-out to historic events, but does not achieve anything if developing nations are not willing or unable to stop themselves doing the same
…it’s cyclic driven by want rather than need.China and the US etc may not have been the big poluters in the past…but they are now, and they will be in the future…1.3billion Chinese are looking to have the same lifestyle as we have in the west…and why not…the big difference is they have already noted the cyclic elements of development = pollution
” between 1791 and 1831 the population of England and Wales grew at an unprecedented rate: from about 7.7 million to 13.2 million and it was to double again to around 25 million by the 1860s. The Scottish population grew much more slowly doubling from around 2 million to 4 million during the whole period from the 1780s to the 1860s.” now put this into the contex of growing industrialisation in for example: China… http://www.ehs.org.uk/industrialrevolution/PH_index.htm
If the commercial giants of wind want to make a change…they should look further a field…and make a real change. Using Scotland as a Shop window is wrong for Scotland (and I refer in total only to commercial windustrial wind)
China is already doing it’s own thing (state owned in entirety of course)…so why do folks feel we will lead the world by example…they already accept we messed up.
- Thanks Cpt Kirk, I rarely look at the site,…quite an insight and definately on par with the worst articles I have seen on such spoof websites…
Off for a cuppa. “beam me up Scotty renewables”.
- “Another place, another argument with a Scottish anti-wind activist who wants to know how much CO2, on a global percentage basis, will be removed from the atmosphere if Scotland meets her 2020 targets”…
I simply can’t let this go…you are the author of spurious mis-information on your website. Now this can either be down to your inability to accept an individual does not agree with commercial wind, and is yet at the same time able quite easily to actively supports community wind; to the point where he was actively involved in building a turbine…(come to Tiree, it’s the large grey structure with 3 blades)…or a blatant lie brought about by your inability to tell the truth….
On this basis alone you have no credibility as a useful or indeed honest source of objective information.
If anything your website is totally counterproductive to the renewables cause.
The article you have written then continues to be riddled with mis-information that the ill informed could be fooled into actually thinking is objective fact. Is this the way you expect to be able to change the current problems we find the world in Webcraft…who are your mentors ? it certainly is not the renewables industry, they show far more intellect in their arguments.
In future and free of charge would you like to forward me such articles and I ensure you they will become objective/informative/ and above all truthful and indeed useful.
Your are also lacking a total for your cumulative emissions what happened to the other 28+%…oh, don’t answer that…it’s too blatantly obvious !
(edit: Scots Renewables/webcraft subsequently removed inflamatory references.)
- Thanks..saved me the trouble…note China V USA webcraft. QED
Aye webcraft…”excellent data” for the case against industrialisation of our “least damaged most natural places” I would say…
I suggest you print this out and place it above your laptop. Errr where is Scotlands co2 out-put…oh there it is… that misplaced pixel off out towards the Iceland !
As for historic data…excuse me but there seems to be something at odds here…are we not trying to reverse current trends to gat back to pastures once green… Webcraft ? or is the entire renewables campaign and search for alternative power sources wrong in your books…f
Anyhow there I go again wasting another nano-second..
off to pastures new , Take 2
- When does picking a fight equate to asking for an answer from a supporter of industrial wind power ?
“Scotland’s overall global contribution to CO2 reduction will be a very small number as a percentage. It will however be disproportionately large compared to her population.”
Yes I agree, out of scale in comparison with both it’s land mass and population…the problem is even though we may meet our targets…the global CO2 emmissions still rise. As a further break down you might want to take other renewables out of the pot..and focus solely on wind…after all is this not what this discussion is about.
In regards to China…please get your facts right…they are the fastest growing producers of CO2 and are expected to over take the USA’s emissions within a 10 year period. The USA will also continue to produce more CO2..(trends up in both cases)
“I don’t intend to enter into a discussion with you about subsidies, except to say that most authorities agree that onshore wind will be competitive without subsidy by 2016. It seems strange to me that you and your fellow travellers want to scrap a new technology just before it becomes competitive.”
It is not like industrial wind has just appeared ! go take a look at a time line. There we go…ZERO. and also you revert again to the economist spin of “competitive”…and have the gall to seperate onshore and offshore wind…they are the same industrial/commercial beast.
Please do not tell un-truths, it does nothing for your credibility…. I have never mentioned scrapping a new technology “wind” (not that wind is that new eh ) I have always and always will support community wind/renewables ventures…I suggest you re-read all of my posts..and note that common thread.
I will revisit the issue in 2016…I think you will find that this, if not before, will be the year in which the coffin nail will finally be driven home…
Time to move on to a new issue.
Recent comments by Karl Hughes
- The independence campaign: personal gains and loss
Well it look’s like they will get a chance to chase it…two new polls, two leads for ‘No’…swing to No in the undecided….
Anyhow…just hope the disapointed on Friday can move on.
- Indy: separating sheep and goats on Brent Crude and house prices
They are…all the way to the bank….
Oil prices are going to stay stable as long as the middle east and US etc are working together…they are then going to drop as Iraqs oil, and Iranian oil comes on line…there accesible reserves are vast…their proven reserves larger…big players here, Saudi does not want Iraq in OPEC…come to your own conclusions as to why wars happen
this is an old article, poke about and you will find something better…
anyhow…if anything oil prices will drop over the next 25 years… cheap fuel drives profit, expansion, capitalism…
- Indy: separating sheep and goats on Brent Crude and house prices
Just think where we would be if there had been no Darien project, you are full of total rubbish NHC… I have not read one constructive post from you in 2 weeks…nothing to add to either view point. Face it you have no idea of what is going on do you ( rhetorical)… not a clue..
“Once China and others move out of recession the price will go up as will demand due to world population increasing” thats got to be the most bonkers statement I have ever read, what the hell are you taking…
You are going to have to live in the “now” very shortly and its going to be a big, big shock…to you. But maybe not eh, maybe you don’t even live in Scotland ? and this is just an extension of your false persona… your living a lie…thats why you are so angry… you want to be a part of something, but actually you know you can’t… thats the truth is it not… dont bother answering… because you mean sweet FA to me or anybody else…..
I suggest we ignor this moronic individual… it will drive it mad… give it time to think ( yea right bit of an oxymoron I know)
- Karl Hughes: What part would an Independent Scotland be able to play in the global war against IS?
Aye…I have probably opened the gates of biblical waffle from NCH…and I will be cast onto the pages of the little black book…LOL… frankly, I’m done with this referendum, what will be will be… I’m not here to change anybodies stance… I just want folk to make an informed decision…my vote is cast, but I have to say…for whatever reason…these 11th hour promises (supposedly on the table already) were in my humble opinion wrong, simply because some folks who have voted…YES or NO were not in possession of all the facts.
Change will come…lets just ensure whatever the outcome we work together to get the best deal we can as parents & people…if its a YES, then we have to ensure Holyrood are held to account and never screw us around…if its a NO we have to do the same with Westminster…but more than anything we have to remember we are just people and that having an identity attached to us… be that Scot, Welsh, Irish, Iraqi, Japanese or whatever is basically bollocks… we all just want to belong…we already do folks !!! we are human. Cast ya votes wisely.
Footnote added a bit later: Yep, its been a journey for me too this referendum, perhaps I have pre-empted everybodies time of reflection having already posted my vote ?
I can’t be a nationalist, its just not me, I see it as a retrograde move and to dictatorial… (but peoples opinions are there own)…Unionism is a progressive idea in my own humble opinion…but there is something greater to aim for and I feel watching and being part of the goings on…thinking about my part in all of this, however small, as moved me on a bit… internationalism, no tags, no borders, no racism,or bias …less selfishness are centuries away (if we get there at all)… anyhow thats where my thoughts are…. thanks to all who will vote or not for making me think outside the cage that we allow politicians to put us in, I feel like its time to go home and wash that muddy “Welcome” mat.
- Argyll and the Isles’ Secrets Collection: Dunadd Fort
I’ve just been looking through some photos of Callanish Standing stones…
And actually and honestly…Yes or No…Union or No Union, Scotland now, or Scotland then…its really all bollocks….we are just pawns…not the player…Time is the player…
I wonder what the folks who raised Callanish called Scotland ? called the British Isles…? they probably just called it home…
If there is just one thing I have finally learnt thanks to this referendum, its that my family come first, without question…and in general we are just people on a journey trying to do the best we can for our kids and for our family and friends…tagging oneself with a nationality, marching under a flag…is a weird human trait, we just want to belong…
All embrace the moment you post your vote, whatever you decide is your decision…don’t be disheartened or angry if you do not get what you hope for…embrace the change whatever that may be…but most of all enjoy every moment you can with the ones you love, your families and friends…we only get one chance to raise our own Callanish.
powered by SEO Super Comments