Argyll's online broadsheet.

Jamie McIntyre. Tree planting – yes, it was …

Comment posted A83 closed due to another landslide – now reopened by S.White.

Jamie McIntyre. Tree planting – yes, it was mentioned some time ago but quickly brushed aside in favour of civil engineering options.

There is a drawback to the tree planting solution, time. It takes time for trees, specifically their root systems, to become sufficiently established to bind the soil. In the meantime, the expansion of our ferry services as previously mentioned could provide alternative transport links rather more realistic than the forestry road or the old military road. And who knows, maybe we will come to see the inconvenient stretches of water which separate us as potential highways rather than as barriers. Our forebears did.

There are advantages of reforestation, on the other hand. Trees improve with age, they grow and multiply, providing a long term solution, whereas any man made structure will inevitably deteriorate. And trees could be planted throughout the length of the valley to protect the entire road. Building galleries over that distance would be enormously expensive in comparison and there is no reason that I can see to assume that future landslides would obligingly confine themselves to the spot where a gallery is located.

Recent comments by S.White

  • SW England sees two wind turbines collapse in a week
    Wrong. If they hadn’t been installed to begin with then they wouldn’t be there.
  • Easdale Island dump: situation to be resolved by ‘change of use’ application
    I wonder if anyone else remembers a television comedy serial from several decades past – The Dukes of Hazard – set in the deep south of the USA. One of the main characters, by the name of Boss Hog, was a sleazy local politician, forever fomenting devious scams clumsily assisted by his dimwit nephew. I spent many happy hours chuckling over their shenanigans, and their inevitable exposure and undoing at the hands of the heroes.

    Good heavens! Do we have a re-run in the making, set in a wee hielan’ village? I look forward to the next episode.

  • McGrigor puts the case for biomass in the energy mix but…
    How refreshing – a politician presenting a sensible, reasonable, cogent, forward looking argument. Rare enough at any time, but when it involves so-called “green” issues, doubly so. I hope that his level-headed views prevail, otherwise the wood waste fuel industry could easily go the same way as wind farms, over subsidised and over exploited.
  • Senior academic raises serious questions about wind power – job creation, cost, performance and policy
    The devastating costs, to us, of wind turbines is even worse than what I expected. The wind industry (or racket) really does intend to pick our pockets clean.

    Only one faint glimmer amongst the gloomy predictions – these hideous machines are expected to fall down much sooner than we have been led to expect. So at least we can look forward to the day when these plukes will be removed from the face of Scotland.

  • Argyll and Bute Council planning for resumption of war on rural schools
    I’m not surprised, it was only a matter of time. When the new council failed to grasp the nettle and clear out the trash from Kilmory last May when they were elected, it was only a matter of time before the smell of it would return to haunt them. The sheer jaw-dropping ineptitude of Sneddon and Co. is matched only by their arrogance, so their will be an endless supply of omnishambles while they remain. So far we have had School closures (twice), then the “spygate melodrama, then the Mary’s meals debacle. Oh yeah, I almost forgot, the lavish rebuilding of Sally Loudon’s office suite (twice) to suit her exacting taste while the council were cutting services to everyone else. Now it appears that we are back to school closures again. As I said – endless.

powered by SEO Super Comments