Major success for Argyll and Bute Council education staff and for Kilmodan school

(Updated below) TES Scotland, the leading magazine for the education profession in Scotland, has an article of 1st June 2012 – Fruit from The Skills Tree – demonstrating a highly developmental innovation.

The article takes takes Kilmodan Primary school in Glendaruel to show how this innovation – The Skills Tree – by ‘education development officer’ Aileen Goodall, is working in its current P6 and P7 pilot, for which Kilmodan is one of the chosen schools.

On the way to that core topic, the journalist mentions that  on arrival at the school, the children are rehearsing a production of Red Riding Hood – in French and for a UNESCO event in Glasgow. Unsurprisingly, the school has won an award for the quality of its French teaching – with even maths sometimes taught through that medium, for variety of language development.

Impressing too was the tearoom run at the pupils and which has already won it a Social enterprise award and a place in the finals of the Scottish Education Awards to be announced later this month, in the Enterprise and Employability Across Learning award.

Kilmodan is one of Argyll’s Lazarus schools, selected as a suitable case for closure by the council just 18 months ago. It was vigorously and successfully defended by its parent council and now, with its 19 pupils, two teachers and dedicated classroom assistants, is showing just what a loss it would have been.

The Skills Tree is a very good idea indeed, with positive lifelong benefits in personal development that must impact upon performance and employability at whatever level.

Basically, it asks pupils to think about and describe what skills they are using in whatever they are doing and to record these on their personal Skills Tree on their webpage on the council’s online support system. Aileen Goodall says it’s ‘a vocabulary and a framework for thinking and talking about skills systematically’.

This is effectively the development of a meta skill, the skill of identifying the skills in use.

The pupils are given a list of skills an they choose and record the most appropriate in relation to their activities of the moment. In the TES article, talking to the journalist they mention skills like listening, perseverance, organisation…

Headteacher, Joyce Hawkins, tells TES  ‘We began using the Skills Tree in September, and if you look at what they have done since, you can clearly see the change. Their language has become more eloquent, descriptive and detailed.’

And actually it;s even more than that. The change in the pupils’ language is the external manifestation of a change in their thinking, the level of their awareness of what they are doing and their understanding of it.

This sort of self analysis cannot be other than substantially developmental for the children. Knowing what you are doing in the way you approach work brings control in moving on to make conscious choices in the skills you apply to any challenge.

This approach will help young children to develop a level of strategic thinking and planning that will stand them in the best possible stead as individuals, team members and team leaders.

Asking them not just to tick what seems like the name of the skill in use in a moment of a given task but to describe it in operation has been noted by the children to be even harder. This mean that the system as a whole is building secondary skills and insights on the back of the Skills Tree itself.

One child quoted, having chosen ‘perseverance’ as the skills he had to deploy in leaning knots, said it was far harder to find words to describe what he was actually doing.

Which of us cannot empathise with that? The greatest enduring conundrum for any adult is how on earth we once learned to tie our shoe laces – and quite how anyone explained it to us.

The Skills Tree is an inspired development which will be adopted widely elsewhere. It will benefit children in their learning, their employability and their management of their lives. The self-questioning analytic methodology will become instinctive in whatever they do and will give them a level of control and task management many would not develop without this experience.

In use at Kilmodan it is proving not only valuable but widely popular and valued. We asked one parent with two daughters at the school, how ‘his girls’ were getting on with it. The answer was: ‘They love it. All 3 of them.’

And if the TES description of Aileen Goodall as an ‘education development officer’ means that she is employed as a ‘Quality Improvement Officer’ then she has proved their potential worth, she has generated genuine improvement – and this is a far more grounded title for the concept of her job.

Update: Reader Walter Burton sent us this link to a downloadable Enterprise Newsletter from Argyll and Bute Council:   This contains more information within in on this project.gthe information at the end also establishes that Aileen Goodall is an Educational Development Officer – not a Quality Improvement Officer. This keeps the pressure on the question of just what the very many  QIOs at Argyll and Bute council actually do and whether that is worth what it costs us. And how many Education Development Officers are there?

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • LinkedIn
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Print

16 Responses to Major success for Argyll and Bute Council education staff and for Kilmodan school

  1. Yet another success for a school the previous administration, and in particular Cllr Marshall’s criteria, would have us believe is failing.

    A little encouragement and a little support and our rural schools can, and do, demonstrate quite how effective they are and quite how well they deliver education.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. So, is this Aileen Goodall one of these much maligned immprovement officers we keep hearing newsie and FA rubbishing??


    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • We could do chapter and verse on QIOs in general and in particular but it seems thrawn to do that right at the moment because our hope is that things will improve under new political guidance.

      ARSN was always aware that QIOs follow instructions from their employer and indeed it was obvious that some were uncomfortable with the roles they had during the closure consultations, not least the dreadful scripts they had to read from (Vygotsky indeed!).

      Now that there’s a new administration, we hope to see more of the kind of work Aileen Goodall is doing. Given all the negative tensions involved in the closure debacle, I’m sure it’s what our QIOs would rather be doing.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        • Just checked our time logs. We posted the update at 08.23 and Simon’s comment to which Barmore 2 refers was posted at 09.09.
          I had done this time log check myself and had not noticed the days, only the hours.
          Simon posted his comment on 3rd June at 9.09pm.
          Our update to the article was on 4th June at 08.23am.

          Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. It is certainly very interesting to hear what has been happening in Kilmodan.Has this been successful in the other schools across Argyll?
    I would love to hear from the teachers and support staff on the closure story now that they are allowed a voice without
    the threat of disciplne.Or have all the bosses seen the light.Still a lot of money being paid to the QIO,s or is this new title a change or additional staff?
    I would hope that the education department and Carol Walker,s so called leadership will be examined very quickly by the new council along with giving us the answers to spygate and Jo Smith.Is she still sitting at home being paid to get a sun tan.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • Well said Barmore 2. Kilmodan deserve our congratulations, as do all the wee schools who keep clocking up one prize or another for doing really special and wonderful work.

      I reckon Argyll & Bute always had the best chance of implementing the Curriculum for Excellence because the wee schools already had to operate that way to an extent and the teachers really know how to make it work. Let’s hope they’re allowed to flourish now so the kids, and their communities, can move forward with security and confidence.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. Yes – well done to EDOs, so why shouldnt all the QIOs become EDOs?
    And I hope that Neil McIntyre gets the answers to his questions quickly – I cant think of a good reason why he shouldnt.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. Regarding the update which reads ‘Auileen Goodall is an Educational Development Officer – not a Quality Improvement Officer. This keeps the pressure on the question of just what the very many QIOs at Argyll and Bute council actually do and whether that is worth what it costs us’

    This is an important point of discussion. It would be interesting to know what are the remits of both roles and how much overlap is there. Based purely on title (which can obviously be misleading) they certainly appear to be roles which must have a lot of similar responsibilities. Are we getitng value for money from these two roles?

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • I think the best people to enquire this with would be Head Teachers across Argyll & Bute and perhaps ask them to list the areas they have received help or have found QIOs and QIMs to actually have been a benefit to them.

      I already know the thoughts of one area – so I would expect much silence to follow such a request.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  6. Surely after the chaos of the rural schools proposed closures the points made by Integrity and Crazy in response to this story would be a great place to start for our new councillors The investigation into duplication of responsibility across the whole spectrum of council departments will surely follow.Jobs can be created and services improved if someone has the sense and guts to do it.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  7. I expect the new Lead Councillor on Education, who knows his area of reponsibilty , possibly better than his appointed staff, to lay down the law to his staff as to policies and guidance. The days of paid staff laying down policy, and failing to give correct information to the elected members and the Council as a whole, are over. One such occurrence such as we have seen in the last few years will lead, I hope, not to resignations and “settlements” but to termination with no recompence. The first real test will probably come in the next 2 weeks with the report on Spygate and the dealing with the culprits in that affair.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

All the latest comments (including yours) straight to your mailbox, everyday! Click here to subscribe.