Comment posted Council Elections: The count by newsroom.
And we don’t bother so much here about the state Iraq has been left in by our illegal intervention.
It’s a matter of scale, Simon but it’s the same thing.
We have all to try to understand the condition of the other.
If one is a townie or a teuchter – to use the pejoratives for both – one cannot ‘know’ what it is to be the other; but one can ask, discover and intuit.
The problem with the school closures was driven, in part, by the phenomenon you identify: urban-based councillors adopting a position on rurality with no experience or understanding of rural communities, the way they work and they way they can fail.
It was the complacent assumption that a position of ignorance was somehow a qualification for superior wisdom that was the can of petrol in this inflammation.
In this case, as you rightly say, the people of Helensburgh didn’t and don’t think rural schools lke Luss and Kilcreggan matter much. Campbeltown cared as much for Southend; Oban for Barcaldine; Rothesay for North Bute; and Dunoon for Toward.
Why should they. It’s not their experience.
But that cannot be the basis for deciding, uninformed, on other people’s lives – or for ganging up on them.
Yet each of these places unknown to townsfolk is a rich and individual culture, a living organism that keeps alive much of the country. If these places die, then alternative means and values for living die too.
It’s not straightforward but it matters.
newsroom also commented
- Sorry Paula. That is flatly incorrect and you cannot therefore have any evidence for it whatsoever.
In our entire lifespan we have blocked fewer than 10 comments – and that’s allowing for memory loss. They have been blocked because they were fully actionable, scatological or smearing for political advantage.
We have also banned one person permanently because he persisted in clear libel in what was clearly a personal obsession that had nothing to do with anyone else.
We sin-binned another for a period for an instance of outrageously poisonous manipulation.
If anything, we should arguably have blocked a lot more comments, not in our own interests – it is patently obvious that we let anyone say what they like about us – but to offer more protection to some individuals than we have done.
We have perhaps been overly tolerant in such cases because we prefer contributors to self-edit in the interests of observing a basic standard of civility and we believe that most people will do so.
- Thank you. It can, of course, be added at any time.
- All that we can think of here is that any comment you are aware of as unpublished may have been written without the ‘Post comment’ button being properly activated.
Two of us have been sharing the monitoring of comments over the life of this article and neither of us has blocked a single comment – something we have almost never had to do.
- Simon – just lose the blinkers and read what’s being said. There was no suggestion that there is anything wrong with ‘urban based’ anythings.
This was a serious response to your comment. It’s important to try the ‘what ifs?’ What if this is a serious matter and not a squib?
If it wasn’t a serious point but merely another squib through our letter box, then there is no use trying to engage. Email your address and we’ll send you a box of Bengal matches to play with.
- We will publish an article on some of these issues later this evening.
The election is also not fully over yet. The Dunoon contest had to be postponed because of the recent death of Councillor Alister McAlistrer, who was due to stabnd in Dunoon.
That vote is being held on Thursday 10th May and Dick Walsh is one of the candidates. The overall picture will not be clear until that ward election is completed.
Recent comments by newsroom
- Lancaster aircraft mystery?
Many thanks for this – and that resolves the noise question.
- Lancaster aircraft mystery?
A Hercules regularly flies up and down Loch Fyne – and sounds very heavy in the air. Even when you don’t see it, you recognise it. Since it flies the same route it must be making routine journeys between the same places – but we don’t know what its purpose is or where it’s going. Islay?
The two planes sighted flying together yesterday were described as ‘quite quiet’ and ‘slender’.
- Salmond pledge at Arbroath: seriously crackpot stuff
This gig has been so bitterly divisive that that few, if any, are likely to accept the decision with grace, whatever it is; or respond with grace to either triumph or defeat. The 19th August and after is a matter for dread all round.
Have you seen this one?
- Swinney urgent to find new owners for Ferguson’s shipyard
An obvious immediate order would see the Deputy First Minister make a courtesy briefing visit to the Dunoon Gourock Ferry Action Group and then commission from Ferguson’s two new passenger ferries for the Gourock-Dunoon town centres route.
- Porkie from Salmond on fiscal policy as Darling bests him again in Reporting Scotland interviews
Of course you and Bismarck [a hugely interesting politician] are right. It is always worth knowing of other people’s experiences and of their economic strategies. This sort of knowledge though is useful as a growing repertoire of how instruments can be used, rather than as a template for replication.
It;s hard to think of a single example of one country successfully replicating the integrated strategies pf another.
It’s about understanding the nature and texture and quirks of your own individual state – and, politics being the art of the possible, making the recipe fit the rhyme.
powered by SEO Super Comments