ForArgyll.com: Argyll's online broadsheet.

Your response is curious. Why would you …

Comment posted SNP need to back off the ‘Anti-Scottish’ tactic by Anne Baird.

Your response is curious. Why would you doubt what I wrote? Have I come across as a liar before?

Tommy Sheridan stood in Pollok constituency. Pollokshields is a couple of miles from Pollok and Pollokshaws is a mile or so from both. Pollok Country Park touches the edges of all three. Check it on a map if you’re anxious.

And yes I did read the rest of the threads. I just wasn’t much concerned about the blethering. I only commented because I see the potential for people that I regard as an intrinsic part of the Scottish fabric to be alienated or made fearful and I think people need to think about that before they go chucking names about.

Anne Baird also commented

  • And I’d suggest he’s never been in the same room as Alex Salmond. Love him or loathe him, he’s the furthest thing from Captain Mainwaring as it’s possible to get.

    Gus’ identification with Lance-Corporal Jones is interesting though and his more frequent cry was “DON’T PANIC!” whilst revolving with his rifle pointed at the various members of the cast. Which neatly describes this thread really …

  • In the eighties I campaigned for the SNP in Pollokshields in Glasgow which has a high percentage of asians in the population. After knocking a dozen or so doors I became perturbed about the look of fear on some of the faces who answered those doors. Eventually I found a feisty woman who was quick to tell me that the Labour party had told her the SNP was the Scottish branch of the BNP. She took it from my wordless tears that frightening people had been the last thing on my mind.

    For that reason I object strongly to any hint of a connection between the SNP and the BNP. The SNP I’ve been in for thirty years has members from many nations including England and the chances of it becoming racist are about the same as it becoming unionist. It may be fair comment that the silly season has broken out with the whole name calling thing, but linking it to the nastier brands of nationalism has real consequences that we should ALL take care to avoid.

Recent comments by Anne Baird

  • Thuggish Yes campaign benefits from media’s artificial ‘balance’ as Murphy forced to suspend campaign tour
    The assassination threats were made via the police and gave detail of locations of explosives. The police were never going to dismiss that. The culprit was given a year in jail and Alex Salmond continued to campaign.

    Jim Sillars received messages indicating some glee on the death of his wife and saying that arrangements were being made for him to join her. Pretty sickening, but Jim continued to campaign.

    Jim Murphy had an egg thrown at him and quit. Efforts are being made within the YES camp to ensure that all pictures and video footage are passed on to police and a concerted effort is being made to identify the man whose face emerges in those.

  • Sir Ian Wood: Young voters must know Scotland will have little oil and gas output when they are middle aged
    You are right Richard. I meant new as in hitherto untapped but it was not clear. It’s nonetheless massive and it’s just one of several being explored. We could build a lot of infrastructure and savings with that before it runs out. Here’s the BBC take.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-north-east-orkney-shetland-23681061

  • Sir Ian Wood: Young voters must know Scotland will have little oil and gas output when they are middle aged
    Even the BBC got hold of the new, and quite massive, finds in the Clair field. Or do you really believe David Cameron took time out from his Ww3 crisis to fly out to Shetland to visit a handful of No voters and have a wee peek at some puffins? Plenty of evidence for this if you bother to look.
  • Managed protest at Pacific Quay shames pro-indy campaign
    Please don’t define a whole party on the basis of one person who may or may not be a member. There are many of us with positive things to say who aspire to a better future for all Scots. We may disagree how that might be achieved, but most of us are acting in good faith.
  • No nationalist politicisation of the Games?
    Richard, I totally take on board that there are two sides to that story and am no great fan of Hamas either, but you only have to look at the difference in the map between 1949 and now to see who’s under threat in Israel/Palestine. The horrible reality is that there are 250,000 kids in an area not quite the size of the Uists and they’re all under fire with nowhere to run. Many aren’t old enough even to know they’re Palestinian and they deserve protection regardless of what the adults around them are up to. I don’t see that as bias and, if it is, I share it with Amnesty International and have done for most of the thirty years I’ve been a member.

powered by SEO Super Comments

· · · · · · · · · · ·


Related Articles & Comments