Argyll's online broadsheet.

Some confusion here? Why should bin liners have …

Comment posted Quite where do police want campers and walkers to look for Suzanne Pilley’s body by Robert Wakeham.

Some confusion here? Why should bin liners have anything to do with which road was travelled?

Robert Wakeham also commented

  • Could have driven a whole variety of routes as far as anyone seems to know.
  • By the way, it’s Inveraray.
  • You assume that, because of the sighting at Tyndrum (and presumably at Inveraray?) – combined with the police search around the Rest – that the answer is east of Inveraray, rather than on the Lochgilphead side, or elsewhere.
    That’s why I think it would be sensible of the police to state clearly what is, and isn’t, known about where Gilroy was known to have been, and at what time. This could save people from getting the wrong ideas about where the body might be. This isn’t the first, or the second, time someone who’s been murdered has been dumped in Argyll in the last few decades.
  • Why shouldn’t the bin liners have been used anywhere, why do you think they were a red herring? The very fact that he obtained them in Lochgilphead increased suspicion – and wasn’t the search on the Rest route reportedly based on mobile phone records? Why do you link the bin liners specifically to the Rest?
  • Well spotted; not only is the most direct route between Tyndrum and Inveraray nowhere near the Rest, there are other routes unless it’s certain that the car went through Inveraray. And the state of the car seems to indicate it either went off the edge of a road – without getting irredeemably stuck – or it went along a hill track or along a stretch of forestry road that had been abandoned or never completed. A great deal of ‘if’s, and a definitive statement from the police would surely be sensible to avoid unnecessary public concern.

Recent comments by Robert Wakeham

powered by SEO Super Comments

· · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ·

Related Articles & Comments