Many thanks. This is very helpful. …

Comment posted Was this a fair tender process? Government cuts Orkney ferry frequencies within days of Serco contract award by newsroom.

Many thanks. This is very helpful.

newsroom also commented

  • We gave the information direct from the government tender document – which is hardly unresearched.

    If you have other documentary evidence to the contrary, why not give links to it so that readers may see it for themselves, rather than make what at the moment are unsupported declarations?

Recent comments by newsroom

  • Salmond pledge at Arbroath: seriously crackpot stuff
    This gig has been so bitterly divisive that that few, if any, are likely to accept the decision with grace, whatever it is; or respond with grace to either triumph or defeat. The 19th August and after is a matter for dread all round.
    Have you seen this one?
    https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=10203458425014450&set=vb.1627816588&type=2&theater
  • Swinney urgent to find new owners for Ferguson’s shipyard
    An obvious immediate order would see the Deputy First Minister make a courtesy briefing visit to the Dunoon Gourock Ferry Action Group and then commission from Ferguson’s two new passenger ferries for the Gourock-Dunoon town centres route.
  • Porkie from Salmond on fiscal policy as Darling bests him again in Reporting Scotland interviews
    Of course you and Bismarck [a hugely interesting politician] are right. It is always worth knowing of other people’s experiences and of their economic strategies. This sort of knowledge though is useful as a growing repertoire of how instruments can be used, rather than as a template for replication.
    It;s hard to think of a single example of one country successfully replicating the integrated strategies pf another.
    It’s about understanding the nature and texture and quirks of your own individual state – and, politics being the art of the possible, making the recipe fit the rhyme.
  • Salmond’s ‘sterlingisation’ Plan B1 would cause chaos as a transitional stop gap
    What we have written is no scare story – but an attempt to explain WHY using a sterlingised Scottish pound would carry high specific risks and limited reward.
    If anyone would care to dispute the reasoning for any of the consequences to which our analysis points, that woould be fun.
  • Porkie from Salmond on fiscal policy as Darling bests him again in Reporting Scotland interviews
    The adversarial stance distorts so much – and is at the heart of our silly, wasteful and expensive politics.
    The examples of other countries are never that relevant because no two situations are the same and no two sets of governing politicians are the same. And then there’s context – which can mean that the same situation with the same politicians in charge but in a different context will not be amenable to being resolved in the same way.
    If the means of achieving a successful economy were replicable, no economy in the world would fail.
    So while it is enriching to experience other economies, one can only learn from them some useful generalities. [And one can envy them. One can also emigrate. And conscious decisions to emigrate because of a discovered affinity with another place and the way of it can be very interesting.] Copying the specifics of what another economy does is plain daft because our country is not the same; our natural resources are not the same; our historic skills and expertise are not the same; our climate is not the same; our philosophy is not the same; our temperament and our values are not the same; and our inherited condition is not the same.
    That’s why what matters is an understanding of the instruments in the tool kit – like, in this case, monetary and fiscal policy, their common purpose and their overlaps. This grasp enables one to make one’s own decisions, that are right for the moment, right for the culture, right for the place and right for the specific challenge.
    So we’re au fait with the instruments, the process of using them and the consequences of using or abusing them in particular ways.
    But we have no detailed idea how any other economy works – because it’s irrelevant to us and our situation.
    However, a lie is a lie, whoever tells it; and being a politician should not be assumed to convey a licence to tell lies.

powered by SEO Super Comments

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • LinkedIn
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Print

8 Responses to Many thanks. This is very helpful. …

  1. Well I wait with baited breath to see how The Doc, DMH, Morag, Anne and the rest of the usual suspects put a positive spin on this, the latest bit of chicanery by the SNP!

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. @ Newsroom: You will find up-to-date transport statistics on the Transport Scotland website. To save you from having to search for it yourselves, here’s the link to the 2011 figures.
    http://www.transportscotland.gov.uk/strategy-and-research/publications-and-consultations/j205779-00.htm
    Given traffic levels on the Pentland Firth service mid-winter — the midday crossing usually only carries a handful of vehicles, often in single figures — I am left wondering if any other bidder saw savings to be made by omitting it when really it’s not needed. Yes, I know it’s supposedly a ‘Lifeline Service’, but be realistic about this — there are still two other NorthLink sailings and also Banksie’s catamaran running three times a day too. Did Northlink themselves (or anyone else) bid to run three runs every day? Without knowing that, criticising Serco is a bit harsh in this instance.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. “When the change of service provider was announced following the tendering process, Orkney and Shetland were assured that they would see improvements to the services. Is this it?”

    I am sure Transport Scotland will find some way to claim its a better service. The claim does not need to have any basis in reality. Look at the improved service we got in Dunoon with bigger boats!

    Does the Orkney service include relief vessels or has that been “improved” so that sailings get cut in half anytime a vessels breaks down or needs serviced – as in Dunoon.

    It is a good point about the contract being changed immediately after companies bid, though presumably even Transport Scotland were not stupid enough to leave themselves exposed.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. The forArgyll article stated “The issue with which we are concerned is whether this substantial change of required service provision, coming to son after the award of contract, invalidates the tender”

    But, as I now understand it, the tender specification essentially invited bidders to reduce from 3 to 2 return crossings per weekday for the non-peak period. The non-peak period was not specified and had to be defined by the bidder.

    So most of this article was un-researched forargyll speculation about an article read somewhere else and then regurgitated as news and information.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • We gave the information direct from the government tender document – which is hardly unresearched.

      If you have other documentary evidence to the contrary, why not give links to it so that readers may see it for themselves, rather than make what at the moment are unsupported declarations?

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. Having watched Question Time the other night, I was astounded at the paucity of comment in favour of the union. Even Forsyth made an idiot of himself.

    It does appear, yet again, our very own SNP are leading the charge for a ‘NO’ vote in 2014. Their defense probably will be something to do with Green issues or European rules…

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


All the latest comments (including yours) straight to your mailbox, everyday! Click here to subscribe.