Comment posted Marine Scotland identifies 15 new Scottish sea areas for offshore wind by Alex McKay.
Robert is quite right that the areas shown on the map are indicative only showing areas for “research” and NOT areas which will inevitably have windfarms. Indeed, this map should not have come as quite such a surprise to Newsroom, with their highly emotive and ridiculously OTT language “the recoil of a rape”, as this looks like a redraw of a map published last March by Offshore Wind Scotland, a consortium of HIE, SE and the Scottish Goverment: http://www.offshorewindscotland.org.uk/index.php/journey_to_2050/scotlands_offshore_wind_sites
The new map enlarges some of the areas, especially in the Clyde, but the indication of joining Islay to Barra and blocking the north end of the Minch were on the earlier map.
Alex McKay also commented
- Newsroom. I don’t deny you legitimate concern, but you appear to have decided when writing your article to assume that all the areas indicated would end up completely covered in turbines, which a reading of the whole report instead of a glance at just one of the maps it contains would have made clear, so in my view your language was unwarranted, e.g. “unhinged”, “brutalist”,”rape”, “effectively unnavigable”, Frankenstein deskbound madness”. Offshore wind developments are going to happen, and what this new report deserves is cogent argument and considered responses not an OTT reaction such as yours.
Recent comments by Alex McKay
- Council Planning Committee meeting on 21st January promises to be lively – as 2 MSPs call for postponement
Agnes. Fulton has been asked for evidence for his statements, so it seems fair to ask you to please provide *your* evidence that there is “a connection between nuclear facilities to cancer clusters in the local population”.
- Baillie scores off a penalty as Swinney wisely back tracks on stamp duty
What “vast majority”, Agnes? Is this wishful thinking or a failure to keep up to date?
The Panelbase Scottish poll in the Sunday Times has Westminster voting intentions of CON 14%, LAB 31%, LDEM 3%, SNP 41%, UKIP 7%.
ICM late December Scottish poll shows the same as other companies – Westminster voting intentions are CON 13%, LAB 26%, LDEM 6%, SNP 43%, UKIP 7%, GRN 4%.
- Scottish Land & Estates asks for unambiguous definition of ‘sporting estate’
“domestic grazing”? That’s a suggestion by someone ignorant of the very poor farming potential of the types of land involved and of the present state of hill farming in Scotland today. Farming in Scotland, and especially hill farming, is almost wholly dependent on EU subsidies. The sheep population of Scotland has declined by over 15% in the last 10 years, simply because it isn’t profitable, with disproportional reductions on hill land. Try again.
- 6 year low for Brent crude – now below $50
It isn’t to someone who has actually bothered to look up on what the price of a litre of petrol is dependent. Try looking i[ a few facts before opening mouth and inserting foot, next time!
- Delays to Stornoway port works postpone linkspan closure at Ullapool
All I can see in either of your contributions is a long list of what *could* be done but not a single mention of the costs of any of them. Just claiming that they “will be far cheaper” *might* be true, but then on the other hand those making the decisions *might* know more than you do about relative costs, availability of shipyards, alternative ferries, etc., etc. So, what about some facts instead of mere claims?
powered by SEO Super Comments