Comment posted Inch Kenneth: Mitfords and mysteries by newsroom.
For BFOandC:
You7 have to hope this is true, don’t you? It’s a fun story and it catches the character of both of them.
newsroom also commented
- For Robert Mac from Lynda:
That was medical thoughtlessness on my part. Of course bi-polar condition is not a disease.I have no privileged information on Unity’s condition but her consistent tendency to fairly extreme levels of serial commitment to people and ideas and the energetic attack with which she carried them through has the pathology of being bi-polar.
And if the key official stories about her are both true (although neither is beyond question), trying to kill herself in despair that Germany and Britain were to go to war against each other and having a breakdown that necessitated recovery in a home – these exemplify the other side of this condition.
Who knows? But there is a pathology there that’s potentially interesting for those qualified to pursue it.
Recent comments by newsroom
- Institute of Fiscal Studies economist looks at fiscal context of independent Scotland
The link to Mr Emmerson’s presentation has been given in the article above from the outset.
And – in genuine puzzlement – what precisely do you see as ‘spin’? - Colonsay votes 60%-40% in favour of proposed Marine Harvest salmon farm
Freedom Foods is less and different than it seems.
This article is required reading for any understanding of this tricky situation:
http://forargyll.com/2013/01/rspca-compromised-by-freedom-food-certification-for-farmed-salmon/ - Institute of Fiscal Studies economist looks at fiscal context of independent Scotland
We would be be very happy to answer this question if we could.
But, as things stand, there is no substantive information and economic detail on exactly what economic strategy and its associated policies would be pursued for an independent Scotland.
The First Minister’s ‘Scotland’s Economy’ paper, recently launched, was profoundly disappointing in this respect and, in its lack of economic substance, replaced by ad-man puffery, was damaging to the campaign’s credibility.
We can assure you and anyone, that when such information becomes available – and we are sure it will because it must – we will not be prejudging it but will respond to it with open mind and goodwill and the necessary intelligent scrutiny.
We have WANTED and still want to see a coherent, joined up, strong, imaginative, challenging and achievable strategy and policies put forward for a specific future for Scotland – honestly described in unchallengeably accurate costs and benefits and carving out an identity for Scotland that is realistic and unique.
The extent to which all we are being offered is essentially the status quo with a new badge and a few costly goody bags to entice ‘Yes’ votes could not undermine the ‘independence’ prospectus more thoroughly.
No one can possibly believe that a change of this magnitude can be made without cost to all concerned.
It is necessary is to know the realistic costs, perceive the realistic benefits and decide if the price is worth paying.
We do not believe that the price need be too high or the benefits inconsequential – but as this campaign is being run, the price IS too high and the benefits insubstantial because, in any competent sense, the necessary thinking has not gone on.
What is being proposed is unrealistic, often unspecific and unproductively expensive into the future – and the easy answers are clearly both misleading and dishonest.
This won’t do and it won’t do it. - White smoke rises from Councillor Duncan MacIntyre’s chimney as two-man College of Cardinals settle a deal
Short and sweet for short and sweet: don’t be simplistic.
No one could defend Councillor Robb’s sudden swerve last Thursday, leaving his loyal colleagues like flotsam and jetsam.
But that does not mean that he did not deserve the support he was given by his colleagues when he was given it.
Life is not a simple business. - Russell to make parliamentary statement on rural schools today
In the circumstances of the destructions of the SNP councillors group in the last 12 months, you can hardly expect credibility elevating the importance of ‘collective’ action?
Being ‘collective’ when it suits one to harvest support from others it not what collectivity or collegiality is about.
And many in Argyll now know more than enough about your party, its councillors, its members, its structures and its wonderfully elastic ‘rules’.
powered by SEO Super Comments
Fascinating article. Thanks.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
I wonder whether it is true that Unity used a diamond ring to scratch swastika’s in the window corners of the house on Inch Kenneth and that Jessica went round and obliterated them by putting a hammer and sickle over them.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
For BFOandC:
You7 have to hope this is true, don’t you? It’s a fun story and it catches the character of both of them.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Newsroom – Interesting article on the island but may I just correct you on the bi-polar aspect, it isn’t a disease.
You may have more information on her background but not sure how you came to the conclusion that she had a bi-polar disorder.
If she did have manic-depressive episodes then of course some sympathy and understanding should be offered. If she didn’t, it’s a pity her suicide attempt was unsuccessful.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
For Robert Mac from Lynda:
That was medical thoughtlessness on my part. Of course bi-polar condition is not a disease.
I have no privileged information on Unity’s condition but her consistent tendency to fairly extreme levels of serial commitment to people and ideas and the energetic attack with which she carried them through has the pathology of being bi-polar.
And if the key official stories about her are both true (although neither is beyond question), trying to kill herself in despair that Germany and Britain were to go to war against each other and having a breakdown that necessitated recovery in a home – these exemplify the other side of this condition.
Who knows? But there is a pathology there that’s potentially interesting for those qualified to pursue it.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Lynda – I agree fully, from an historical perspective it is a very interesting story, but I think it is possibly making quite a big jump from someone who may simply of been totally infatuated by someone and their beliefs, to identifying them as being bi-polar.
Most people who are totally besotted by someone can go to extremes and indeed may stalk them but that would be more indicative of an Obsessional Compulsive Disorder (OCD) as opposed to bi-polar.
When an individual has either of these conditions, they are usually clinically evident and the symptoms tend to be very obvious.
As the regime at the time ‘cleansed’ people with mental illness would Hitler entertain someone with such a condition.
From the story above, I personally do not see any indications that she had either of these conditions therefore I am left with the opinion that she supported fascism and was a nazi.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Interesting article.
Ironically, she was conceived in Swastika, Ontario
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
A very interesting article. Was the family home of the second Lord Redesdale in Yorskshire (sic)? I always believed that it came from Redesdale in Northumberland, with a further connection to Mitford in the same county.
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
The current Dowager Duchess of Devonshire, the fifth and youngest of the Mitford sisters, still happily alive, testifies in her wonderful memoir ‘Wait For Me’ that she and her mother (Muv)did indeed take the train to Basle to collect her very ill sister Unity on 31st December 1939 some 3 months after her attempted suicide and returned by hospital train to England; news had come from a friend in Hungary of her whereabouts after being invalided from Munich at Hitler’s expense. She was taken first to a family property Old Mill Cottage near High Wycombe and from there to Mill Cottage in Swinbroke, Oxon. She may have had an affair with an RAF officer in 1941 but she appears to have been quite ill and certainly suffering from severe bouts of depression. After their parents’ separation in 1943 their father eventually went from his home on Inch Kenneth (Mull) to Redesdale c 1950, near the family seat in the village of Mitford in Northumberland, not Yorkshire. Interesting family!
Like or Dislike:
0 
0
Pingback: Argyll News: Tripadvisor names Mull Charters No 2 in World’s 10 great wildlife tours | For Argyll