If I was organising a search for Suzanne …

Comment posted Quite where do police want campers and walkers to look for Suzanne Pilley’s body by Treble T.

If I was organising a search for Suzanne Pilley’s body I would ask dog owners to take their dogs for a walk down every road or track that leads off the Tyndrum to Inverary road as dogs have a very keen sense of smell and are more likely to find a body.

Treble T also commented

  • Thank you for correcting my mistake.
  • According to the court case David Gilroy took an unusual route from Edinburgh to Lochgilphead. He travelled via Tyndrum and Inverary taking two hours to complete the Tyndrum to Inverary section which is a lot longer than normal. The distance between Tyndrum and Inverary is 32 miles which should take about 45 minutes maximum to complete by car.
    I think that David Gilroy dumped Suzanne Pilley’s body between Tyndrum and Inverary before travelling on to Lochgilphead. He then asked for black bin liners to give the impression that he had dumped the body at the Rest and be Thankful. I have also driven several times on the A83 over the Rest and be Thankful. One thing is certain. There are a lot more rough tracks leading off the Tyndrum to Inverary road than there are on the main A83 at Rest and be Thankful. The Rest and be Thankful area is well frequented by hill walkers whereas the few people walk on the tracks off the Tyndrum to Inverary road.
  • David Gilroy collected bin liners prior to leaving Lochgilphead on his return journey to Edinburgh. Lothian & Borders police assumed that the bin liners were for covering the Suzanne Piley’s body prior to disposal somewhere aroung the Rest and be Thankful area.
  • I travel on this stretch of road between Inverary and Tyndrum several times per year. I have often thought that the police should be looking there rather than at the Rest and be Thankful. There are numerous rough tracks leading from the Inverary to Tyndrum stetch of road which could be used by a car at a push.
    I think that the collecting of bin liners from the janitorial staff at Lochgilphead School by David Gilroy was a red herring to divert the police into searching for the body at the Rest and be Thankful.
    In my opinion the road between Inverary and Tyndrum is not a popular areas for dog walkers hence the reason that the body has not been found.

Recent comments by Treble T

  • SNP gain a councillor at Argyll and Bute
    phil.
    As one of his constituents I suggest that you try to shame your local councillor into resigning and standing in a by election in his ward representing the SNP party.
    It would be interesting to see how many votes Iain Angus Macdonald would receive.
    In my opinion councillors should no longer be paid an annual salary and we should return to paying them a laid down fee for attending statutory council meetings.
    That would encourage councillors who rarely attend council meetings to make more of an effort to attend otherwise they would not get paid.
  • SNP gain a councillor at Argyll and Bute
    Richard.
    I am surprised that you do not know about it.
    If a resident phones their local Service Point to complain about something such as a street light not working the call is transferred to the Contact (Call) Centre in Campbeltown where it is logged to justify someone’s existence and eventually repaired.
    Previously if a resident phoned in to complain to their local Service Point about a street light not working it was promptly repaired and usually within 24 hours.
  • SNP gain a councillor at Argyll and Bute
    In my opinion if a councillor resigns from the party he represented at the previous council elections then a byelection should take place.
    That might encourage councillors not “to jump ship” just because they feel like it.
    Iain Angus Macdonald was elected as an Independent Councillor and NOT a SNP Councillor at the 2012 Argyll & Bute council elections.
    If the had stood as a SNP candidate he might not have been elected.
  • SNP gain a councillor at Argyll and Bute
    Argyll & Bute Council could save themselves a lot of money if they got rid of that useless call centre in Campbeltown for reporting faults and allow residents to report any faults to their local Service Point where it would be dealt with more promptly.
    Unfortunately Campbeltown has empire builders who are sitting there trying to justify their own exsistence.
  • Fight for SNP Deputy Leader pits future against past
    In my opinion Keith Brown would be an ideal choice as SNP deputy leader as he has been a disaster as Transport Minister as far as the tourist providers on Islay are concerned.
    As a result of the Ferries Review in March 2013 after the Calmac 2013 Summer Timetables and been printed and distributed, Keith Brown the Scottish Government Transport Minister decided to divert the 9.45am sailing on a Saturday from Kennacraig to Port Ellen to Kennacraig to Port Askaig.
    The Hebridean Isles then sailed to Colonsay where it sat for three hours tied up a the pier at Colonsay doing nothing. It then sailed from Colonsay with a handful of vehicles back to Port Askaig and then on to Kennacraig.
    Saturday is the changeover day on Islay and as a result it is the busiest day of the week for ferries.
    The residents of Colonsay wanted a Saturday sailing from Oban not from Islay but Keith Brown sitting in Ediburgh noticed that there were two ferries serving Islay route and decided to send one of them to Colonsay to keep the Colonsay residents happy.
    Once again Scottish Government Ministers are clueless when it comes to dealing with matters west of Glasgow.

powered by SEO Super Comments

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • LinkedIn
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Print

21 Responses to If I was organising a search for Suzanne …

  1. Well spotted; not only is the most direct route between Tyndrum and Inveraray nowhere near the Rest, there are other routes unless it’s certain that the car went through Inveraray. And the state of the car seems to indicate it either went off the edge of a road – without getting irredeemably stuck – or it went along a hill track or along a stretch of forestry road that had been abandoned or never completed. A great deal of ‘if’s, and a definitive statement from the police would surely be sensible to avoid unnecessary public concern.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. While it would be highly desirable for Suzanne Pilley’s body to be found, not least to help alleviate the inconceivable distress that her family must be suffering, I am quite sure that the police do not want to provide sufficiently accurate enough information to spark off an unofficial public search of a specific area.
    While possibly assisting in locating the body, it would more probably result in destruction of vital clues, thus delaying any find further, and may even attract some questionably motivated people.
    When the authorities are in a position to pin down a specific area (and they will be working on this) I am sure that they will conduct a methodical search, possibly enlisting public assistance at that point.
    In the meantime, encouraging private searches may be with honourable intentions, but could have negative results.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • One’s first thought is why on earth are the police asking the public to help at all.

      Then one wonders if the fact of conviction means that the priority is – reasonably – finding Suzanne Pilley for her family’s sake.

      But then why not give the public accurate guidelines to know whether or not they’re in an area that might be worth – not searching – but keeping their eyes open.

      Overall, this invitation to the public seems no more than half thought.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  3. I travel on this stretch of road between Inverary and Tyndrum several times per year. I have often thought that the police should be looking there rather than at the Rest and be Thankful. There are numerous rough tracks leading from the Inverary to Tyndrum stetch of road which could be used by a car at a push.
    I think that the collecting of bin liners from the janitorial staff at Lochgilphead School by David Gilroy was a red herring to divert the police into searching for the body at the Rest and be Thankful.
    In my opinion the road between Inverary and Tyndrum is not a popular areas for dog walkers hence the reason that the body has not been found.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  4. David Gilroy collected bin liners prior to leaving Lochgilphead on his return journey to Edinburgh. Lothian & Borders police assumed that the bin liners were for covering the Suzanne Piley’s body prior to disposal somewhere aroung the Rest and be Thankful area.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • Why shouldn’t the bin liners have been used anywhere, why do you think they were a red herring? The very fact that he obtained them in Lochgilphead increased suspicion – and wasn’t the search on the Rest route reportedly based on mobile phone records? Why do you link the bin liners specifically to the Rest?

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  5. According to the court case David Gilroy took an unusual route from Edinburgh to Lochgilphead. He travelled via Tyndrum and Inverary taking two hours to complete the Tyndrum to Inverary section which is a lot longer than normal. The distance between Tyndrum and Inverary is 32 miles which should take about 45 minutes maximum to complete by car.
    I think that David Gilroy dumped Suzanne Pilley’s body between Tyndrum and Inverary before travelling on to Lochgilphead. He then asked for black bin liners to give the impression that he had dumped the body at the Rest and be Thankful. I have also driven several times on the A83 over the Rest and be Thankful. One thing is certain. There are a lot more rough tracks leading off the Tyndrum to Inverary road than there are on the main A83 at Rest and be Thankful. The Rest and be Thankful area is well frequented by hill walkers whereas the few people walk on the tracks off the Tyndrum to Inverary road.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • ????? Why would he ask for binliners at all? Why not just go home?

      I’m with you on the dogwalkers though, that will be the answer in the end.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  6. You assume that, because of the sighting at Tyndrum (and presumably at Inveraray?) – combined with the police search around the Rest – that the answer is east of Inveraray, rather than on the Lochgilphead side, or elsewhere.
    That’s why I think it would be sensible of the police to state clearly what is, and isn’t, known about where Gilroy was known to have been, and at what time. This could save people from getting the wrong ideas about where the body might be. This isn’t the first, or the second, time someone who’s been murdered has been dumped in Argyll in the last few decades.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  7. If I was organising a search for Suzanne Pilley’s body I would ask dog owners to take their dogs for a walk down every road or track that leads off the Tyndrum to Inverary road as dogs have a very keen sense of smell and are more likely to find a body.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  8. I don’t know all the facts…like which way the car was heading in the CCTV…but If nobody has yet done it, somebody should have look in the forestry areas on the N side of the road between Tyndrum and the turn off to Inveraray near Dalmally (on the A85 ) dense young conifers and loads of access points…no campers, no access to any popular hill’s and definately no dog walkers. (good forest to see Goldcrests and the likes)

    Folk in Glen Orchy would most likely notice a passing car.

    Suppose he could have driven down the A82 and then along A83 ?

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  9. I have e-mailed L&B about times and direction of travel at Inveraray and still no answer.He turned off phone so how can they know where he stopped the area between port sonachan and ford would be my focus for The search

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  10. Please clear up a few things for me,first of all why do the police think that the rest and be thankful route is involved at all.Secondly do we know which route he took on his return journey from Lochgilphead to Edinburgh.Im so confused by the routes and timing parts of his journey to try and at least rule out where he didnt dump the body,thanks.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


All the latest comments (including yours) straight to your mailbox, everyday! Click here to subscribe.